Saragrahi.org

Saragrahi.org      Second

Third    Fourth    Fifth

In Vaikuntha Not Even The Leaves Fall
"The Origin of the Jiva Controversy"
By Satyanarayana Dasa Babaji & Kundali Dasa

Setting the Scene: 

.

Part-1: “This Book is the Result of Controversy.  In writing it We Were Advised to Downplay the Controversial Aspect”      

Part-2: “This Issue Will be Settled, if At All, in the Marketplace of Ideas”

Part-3: “The Above Letter Sets the Stage.  We Want Our Readers to Note Some of the Salient Features of This Letter”

.

First Wave: Siddhanta

.

Introduction

..

CHAPTER ONE: “The Origin of the Jiva According to Srila Bhaktivinoda Thakura”   

..

Part-1: “In ISKCON, the Question of the Origin of the Jiva Has Come up Again and Again From the Very Beginning”  

Part-2: “When We Study the Writings of Srila Bhaktivinoda Thakura, We Find That Whereas Other Acaryas Previously Explained Anadi in Philosophical Terms he Explained it in a Novel Way”    

Part-3: “The Essence is That There are Three Types of Jivas”

Part-4: “A Class of “Weak” Jivas Exist to Enable the Lord, Who is Lilamaya, to Have the Full Range of Lila”     

Part-5: “If the Jiva had not Been Given Independence, What Would Have Been the Loss?”

.

CHAPTER TWO: “More from the Teachings of Bhaktivinoda Thakura”

..

Part-1: 

Part-2:     

Part-3: 

.

CHAPTER THREE: “The Origin of the Jiva According to Srila Bhaktisiddhanta Sarasvati Thakura Prabhupada”

..

Part-1:       

Part-2:        

Part-3:

.

CHAPTER FOUR: “The Origin of the Jiva According to Srila Prabhupada”

..

Part-1:     

Part-2     

Part-3

Part-4:     

Part-5     

Part-6:

.

CHAPTER FIVE:  “Evidence From Other Acaryas, and From Sruti & Smrti”  

..

Part-1:     

Part-2:     

Part-3:

..

CHAPTER SIX, “Srila Jiva Goswami, No One Falls from Vaikuntha”        

..

Part-1:     

Part-2:     

Part-3:

Part-4:     

Part-5:   

Part-6:

.

CAPTER SEVEN, “Nitya-muktas Never Contact the Material Energy”..

.
.

Part-1:   

Part-2:   

Part-3:

..

CHAPTER EIGHT, “The Meaning of Anadi-I ” 

..

Part-1:     

Part-2:     

art-3:. 

..

CHAPTER NINE, “The Meaning Anadi-II ”

..

Part-1:     

Part-2:     

Part-3:

Part-4:     

Part-5:     

Part-6:

..

CHAPTER TEN, “The meaning of Anadi-III ”.

..

Part-1a:     

Part- 2L   

Part-3:

Part-4L     

Part-5:   

Part-6L

..